Record › Lidar or cameras
Lidar or cameras
Per million miles, Waymo’s robotaxis, on lidar, filed 5.7 crash reports with NHTSA, and Tesla’s, on cameras alone, 12.0. Most of the gap is the robotaxi moving into a fixed object: 6.0 against 0.19. Where someone was hurt or an airbag deployed, the miles are still too few to tell the two apart. Of the 80 self-driving services running today, 65 use lidar and 7 use cameras without lidar, all of them Tesla’s; for 8, no source says.
Crash reports per million miles
NHTSA publishes every crash report from a self-driving system, but no miles, and a count without miles mostly measures the size of a fleet. Two companies publish miles their reports can be set against: Waymo on the lidar side, and Tesla, the only company running services on cameras alone. Reports per million miles; under each, the 95% range and the count:
| Waymo (lidar) 1 Jul 2025 to 30 Jun 2026, 175 million miles | Tesla (cameras, no lidar) 22 Jan to 30 Sep 2026, 2.0 million miles |
|---|
| All reports | 5.7 5.4 to 6.1 · 1,007 reports | 12.0 7.7 to 17.9 · 24 reports |
| The robotaxi was moving | 2.4 2.2 to 2.7 · 424 reports | 7.5 4.2 to 12.4 · 15 reports |
| Moving, into a fixed object | 0.19 0.13 to 0.27 · 34 reports | 6.0 3.1 to 10.5 · 12 reports |
| Moving, into anything else | 2.2 2.0 to 2.5 · 390 reports | 1.5 0.31 to 4.4 · 3 reports |
| Someone injured, as alleged in the report | 0.56 0.45 to 0.68 · 98 reports | 0.50 0.01 to 2.8 · 1 report |
| An airbag deployed, in any vehicle | 0.26 0.19 to 0.34 · 45 reports | 0.0 0.0 to 1.8 · 0 reports |
The two ranges stay apart in 3 rows: all reports; the robotaxi was moving; moving, into a fixed object. In the other 3, they overlap: there, the miles are still too few to tell the two apart.
The other companies’ reports
18 other companies filed reports in NHTSA’s current file, from 16 June 2025 to 15 October 2026, but publish no miles that match them, so the record does not weigh their reports against anyone’s: Aurora (lidar), Avride (lidar), Beep (lidar), Bot Auto (lidar), Gatik (lidar), Hyundai Motor America (not stated), May Mobility (lidar), Mobileye (lidar), Motional (lidar), Nuro (lidar), Ohmio (not stated), Oxa (lidar), PlusAI (lidar), Stack AV (not stated), Torc (lidar), Waabi (lidar), WeRide (lidar), Zoox (lidar).
Who uses which
Each technology company’s answer rests on its own page first, then a press release, a partner’s or supplier’s page, and last a dated press report; the words are quoted as read. “Not stated” means no source on that ladder says. Each quote was last read on its page on 20 November 2026, and is read again every week.
| Side | Companies | Services | Running now | Nobody aboard |
|---|
| Lidar | 26 | 184 | 65 | 38 |
| Cameras, no lidar | 3 | 11 | 7 | 6 |
| Not stated | 14 | 29 | 8 | 3 |
Nobody aboard: running services where all or some trips run with no driver or safety staff aboard.
Every company, and the words its answer rests on
Lidar: 26
- Waymo · 36 services “Strategically placed short-range lidars provide redundant coverage to our cameras” (per the company's own page: Waymo blog, the 6th-generation Waymo Driver, 12 February 2026)
- Baidu Apollo Go · 25 services “its lidar solution will power Apollo Go's landmark expansion into Dubai” (per a partner's or supplier's page: Hesai, lidar for Apollo Go in Dubai, 31 March 2025)
- WeRide · 24 services “including high-performance, low-cost LiDAR, high-definition high-dynamic cameras” (per a press release: WeRide unveils the production robotaxi GXR, 15 October 2024)
- Pony.ai · 17 services “Four AT128 Lidar Sensors from Hesai Selected as Primary Lidar for All Pony.ai Seventh-Generation Robotaxis” (per a partner's or supplier's page: Hesai, lidar for Pony.ai's seventh-generation robotaxis, April 2025)
- Zoox · 12 services “combines cameras, radar, and LIDAR” (per the company's own page: Amazon, Zoox reveals its robotaxi, 14 December 2020)
- ADASTEC · 10 services “Karsan’s Autonomous e-ATAK is equipped with numerous LiDAR sensors” (per a partner's or supplier's page: Karsan, autonomous passenger service at Rotterdam airport)
- Mobileye · 10 services “Equipped with 13 cameras, nine laser scanners (LiDAR), and five radar sensors” (per a partner's or supplier's page: MOIA, autonomous ridepooling with the ID. Buzz AD)
- Aurora · 8 services “Aurora Driver 2, with proprietary FirstLight lidar” (per the company's own page: Aurora, the Aurora Driver)
- May Mobility · 7 services “Aeva's long-range 4D LiDAR technology” (per a press release: May Mobility selects Aeva as production supplier of long-range lidar, 8 November 2023)
- Momenta · 6 services “Ihre Fahrzeuge kombinieren hochauflösende Kameras und Radarsensoren mit sogenannten Lidar-Sensoren” (per a press report: Vision Mobility, Uber and Momenta start robotaxi tests in Munich, 18 November 2026)
- Gatik · 5 services “Gatik uses Velodyne’s lidar sensors to support short-haul logistics” (per a press report: Robotics 24/7, Velodyne Lidar to provide sensors for Gatik, 23 April 2021)
- NVIDIA · 3 services “14 high-definition cameras; nine radars, one lidar and 12 ultrasonics” (per a press release: NVIDIA, robotaxi partnership with Uber, 28 October 2025)
- Waabi · 3 services “multiple sensors such as LiDARs, cameras, and radars” (per the company's own page: Waabi, introducing the Waabi Driver, 15 November 2022)
- DiDi · 2 services “The new Robotaxi model features four Hesai AT128 lidar sensors” (per a partner's or supplier's page: Hesai, lidar for DiDi and GAC Aion's robotaxi, 15 April 2025)
- Einride · 2 services “diverse and redundant sensor suite (camera, radar, lidar)” (per a press release: Einride, voluntary safety self-assessment, 25 March 2026)
- Kodiak · 2 services “Housing LiDAR, radar, and cameras for full 360° coverage” (per the company's own page: Kodiak, technology)
- Nuro · 2 services “High-resolution cameras, lidar, and radars provide 360-degree awareness.” (per the company's own page: Nuro, the Nuro, Lucid and Uber robotaxi)
- Torc · 2 services “LiDAR, radar and camera technology” (per a press release: Daimler Truck and Torc select Aeva to supply 4D lidar, 9 January 2024)
- Avride · 1 service “Five high-resolution lidars provide the system with precise geometry of nearby objects” (per the company's own page: Avride, the Avride driver)
- Bot Auto · 1 service “Five LiDAR sensors, two installed on the truck's top sensor bar” (per a press report: Vision Systems Design, Bot Auto's driverless run, 5 November 2025)
- Kakao Mobility · 1 service “equipped with five LiDAR sensors and seven cameras” (per a press report: Asia Economy, Kakao's driverless taxi in Gangnam, 31 March 2026)
- Motional · 1 service “LiDAR, radar, and cameras sense a full 360 degrees around the robotaxi” (per the company's own page: Motional, its robotaxi on the Hyundai IONIQ 5, 31 March 2021)
- Oxa · 1 service “standard automotive-grade sensors, including cameras, lidar and radar” (per the company's own page: Oxa unveils its autonomous Ford E-Transit van and minibus, 29 October 2024)
- PlusAI · 1 service “Primary: camera + lidar + radar” (per the company's own page: PlusAI, technology)
- Tensor · 1 service “Tensor Robocar is equipped with five advanced lidars” (per the company's own page: Tensor, the Tensor Robocar)
- Zhidao · 1 service “including components such as lidar, millimeter-wave radar, and cameras” (per a press release: MOGOX wins a contract for a driverless bus service in Singapore, 9 October 2025)
Cameras, no lidar: 3
Not stated: 14
How these numbers are made
- Waymo. Miles: rider-only miles, with no human driver. 271.329 million rider-only miles through June 2026, less 95.965 million through June 2025, both from the Safety Impact hub's miles per location. Reports: reports with nobody at the wheel (NHTSA's driver type None or Remote), with an incident month in the window. Sources: Waymo Safety Impact hub, miles per location through June 2025, Waymo Safety Impact hub, miles per location through June 2026.
- Tesla. Miles: miles with no safety monitor in the vehicle. "We reached nearly two million cumulative unsupervised miles for our Robotaxi service as of the end of the quarter" (Q3 2026 Update). Tesla's Robotaxi Safety Report counts miles with no safety monitor in the vehicle from 22 Jan 2026 and gives 3,112,541 by 18 Oct 2026. Nearly two million is taken as two million, so Tesla's rates are a floor. Reports: reports with nobody at the wheel and no safety monitor aboard (a report whose driver type is In-Vehicle, or whose narrative says a safety monitor was present, is left out), with an incident month in the window. Sources: Tesla, Q3 2026 Update, 21 Oct 2026, Tesla, Robotaxi Safety Report.
- NHTSA publishes each report’s month, not its day, so a window runs by whole months.
- A report is filed whoever caused the crash, and one crash can be reported more than once. The injuries are as alleged in the reports.
- The two fleets drive in different cities and months, and lidar is not the only difference between the two systems, so these numbers do not show what lidar causes.
- The crash reports: NHTSA, Standing General Order crash reports, current file to 15 October 2026, published 16 November 2026.
Waymo, Tesla or any company named on this page can send a correction or a statement to driverless@pivotalpoint.io, and it is shown here.
The data behind this page
The data file has every NHTSA crash report joined to the service it happened in, each company’s sensors with the words they rest on, and every source archived as it read on the day. Kept up to date, it adds a new file every week.